Bias in Public Health Education: Where’s the Non-Western Perspectives?

Share
Bias in Public Health Education: Where’s the Non-Western Perspectives?
Photo by Marv Watson / Unsplash

Sam Jarada – The Public Trust

Global Student, Local Curriculum

Reflecting on my earlier public health education, I’ve had this thought: why is there a strong focus on the contributions from people living in Europe and North America? I looked back on an article I wrote called “Key historical events and theories in public health,” seeing how Western-centric it was [1]. This was before I started my Master of Public Health (MPH) degree at Imperial, which exposed me to a broader perspective beyond what I knew at that time. 

With this said, that article was part of the strong foundation and passion that enabled me to pursue an MPH [1]. When going into the course, we had sessions on “decolonising public health” and “intersectionality,” providing me inspiration for my current work. However, I now see that what’s missing is public health’s history from numerous regions and countries as they’ve made contributions too. 

Hence, the present public health curriculum suffers from a geographical and cultural bias by showcasing how Western medicine is the major lineage of public health as currently practiced. This omission distorts history and doesn’t prepare students for an increasingly global healthcare landscape.

The Western Bias and Why It Matters

We’ve all heard of Florence Nightingale, Alexander Fleming, Edward Jenner and John Snow. They’re some of the most well-known pioneers in public health, which should be based on their contributions to the field. Nonetheless, their knowledge and contributions were built not only from their contemporaries and colleagues from Europe and North America, but from those outside of the West. 

The non-Western pioneers, such as those from the Islamic Golden Age or Ancient India, are either not mentioned or seldom discussed within the public health curriculum on the same level as Florence Nightingale and other notable people. This creates an illusion that modern public health was enhanced by the West as opposed to a nuanced reality that the knowledge was shared cross-culturally and evolved from many contexts.

For international students, this bias can be personal; it marginalizes the public health systems of their countries of origin, viewing them as “traditional” or “alternative” rather than foundational to modern public health. This distorts history and undermines the field’s collaborative nature.

Reclaiming and Recognising Global Contributions

To overcome the Western bias, I’ll provide key examples of public health contributions from the non-western contexts below: 

The Islamic Golden Age 

During the Islamic Golden Age, scholars across West Asia, North Africa and Persia translated and expanded medical knowledge from Greek, Persian, Indian, Jewish and Syriac-Christian traditions [2]. 

The Bimaristan, or hospital, provided organised pharmaceutical care, clinical teaching and treatment [2]; they aided in establishing the teaching hospital model and contributed to establishing medicine as a profession.

Also, physicians such as al-Razi and Ibn Sina contributed to clinical observation, medical classification and surgery [2]. Ibn Sina’s Canon of Medicine was later translated into Latin and then used in European medical education [2]. This history challenges the idea that medical knowledge developed mainly from classical Greece into modern Europe.

Ancient India

The Indus Valley Civilisation created planned bathing areas, wells and drainage systems in cities, showing an early concern with environmental sanitation [3]. Furthermore, Ayurvedic texts like the Charaka Samhita and Sushruta Samhita discussed diet, hygiene, disease prevention, diagnosis and medical training [4].

Ancient Indian medicine connected health with the environment, daily routines and social wellbeing [3, 4]. Although Ayurvedic theories aren't the same as current biomedical science, their emphasis on healthy living and prevention are important contributions to public health history [3, 4].

Ancient China 

Similarly, Ancient Chinese health traditions highlighted illness prevention, maintaining cleanliness and disease treatment before it became severe [5, 6]. Historical records describe responses to epidemics, including quarantine or isolation, medicine distribution, treatment facilities and care for affected communities [5, 6].

China developed variolation against smallpox before the emergence of Jenner’s vaccination in Europe [5, 6]. Although variolation had risks and wasn’t based on modern germ theory, it represents an important example of deliberate disease prevention developed outside the West.

Mesoamerica

Mesoamerican societies, particularly the Aztecs or Mexica, created advanced systems of water management and urban sanitation [7]. Tenochtitlan had aqueducts, public bathing facilities, freshwater infrastructure and systems for reusing or removing waste [7, 8].

Additionally, Nahua communities emphasised frequent handwashing, bathing and the use of plant-based soaps [7, 8]; specialist herbal practitioners, healers and midwives had extensive botanical knowledge to treat illness and injuries [7, 8]. These examples counteract the colonial depictions of Indigenous American societies as medically undeveloped.

Importance for Public Health Education

Including these historical facts (among numerous others) shows how public health is a universal achievement. Hospitals, sanitation, epidemic control, preventive medicine and pharmacological knowledge came through numerous traditions and exchanging ideas between cultures. Therefore, a truly balanced curriculum should present non-Western societies not as passive recipients of Western medicine but as active contributors to the development of health knowledge.

Tangible Steps for Educators

To address the Western bias in public health education, educators and institutions can take practical steps to integrate non-Western perspectives:

Diversify Course Materials

  • Include primary sources like Ibn Sina’s Canon of Medicine or the Charaka Samhita to provide firsthand historical accounts.
  • Feature works by modern non-Western scholars to highlight contemporary contributions.

Revise Curriculum Frameworks

  • Develop modules that trace cross-cultural exchanges in public health knowledge.
  • Link public health history to anthropology, sociology and history for a holistic view.

Foster Collaborative Learning

  • Invite guest lecturers from non-Western institutions or Indigenous health practitioners.
  • Encourage student-led research on local or regional public health histories.

Support Faculty Development

  • Establish resource-sharing platforms for educators to access diverse materials.
  • Incentivize faculty who revise courses to include non-Western perspectives.

Advocate for Institutional Change

  • Push for curriculum reviews to assess and update public health programs.
  • Share revised curricula or open-access resources with other institutions.

Towards True Global History

The Western bias in public health education often misses the mark by ignoring the collaborative origins of the field. Acknowledging the contributions from non-Western cultures isn’t meant to downplay the achievements of Western pioneers; rather, it’s about celebrating public health as a collective human triumph.

A genuinely global curriculum would focus on collaboration, question existing hierarchies and equip students for a diverse world. By embracing the entire range of human experiences, we not only enhance the future of public health but also make sure its history tells the whole truth.

Sources

1. Jarada S. Key historical events and theories in public health. Scientia NewsFebruary 2023. Accessed September 21, 2026. https://www.scientianews.org/biology/history-of-public-health 2. Miller AC. Jundi-Shapur, bimaristans, and the rise of academic medical centres. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine. 2006;99(12):615-617. doi:10.1258/jrsm.99.12.615 3. Raj V, Tabassum A. P, Narula J. Contributions of ancient Indian knowledge to modern medicine and cardiology. Indian Heart Journal. 2021;73(5):531-534. doi:10.1016/j.ihj.2021.09.010 4. Prasad B DrH. Public Health in Ancient India: A Historical Review. International Journal of Ayurvedic & Herbal Medicine. 2025;15(02). doi:10.47191/ijahm/v15i2.09 5.Liu CL, Zhou T, Cheng LB, et al. The History of Controlling and Treating Infectious Diseases in Ancient China. Curr Med Sci. 2024;44(1):64-70. doi:10.1007/s11596-024-2831-0 6. Yu X. Response to Epidemic Disease in Ancient China and its Characteristics. Chin Med Cult. 2020;3(2):55-59. doi:10.4103/CMAC.CMAC_22_20 7. Harvey HR. Public health in Aztec society. Bull N Y Acad Med. 1981;57(2):157-165. Accessed 21 September 2026. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7011458/ 8. Birn AE. Public Health and Medicine in Latin America. (, ed.Jackson M). Oxford University Press; 2012. Accessed 21 September 2026. https://academic.oup.com/edited-volume/34385/chapter-abstract/291596632 

Read more